Should You Sell an Investment Property to Pay Off Your Home Loan?

Key Takeaways

  • Home loan interest is not tax deductible and investment loan interest generally is, so $1 of home loan interest costs more after tax.

  • In the worked example, a $1,100,000 sale leaves $543,187 after selling costs, capital gains tax and the investment loan payout.

  • That sum saves about $33,949 a year in home loan interest, against about $1,988 of after-tax rental cash flow and all future growth.

  • From 1 July 2027, negative gearing on established property bought after 12 May 2026 is limited, which makes a sale hard to reverse.

The idea is simple enough. You sell an investment property to pay off the mortgage on your home, stop paying interest that earns no tax deduction and free up cash flow. For some owners it is the right call, while for others it swaps a growing asset for a one-off saving and a tax bill.

Whether it is right for you depends on what the sale leaves after costs and tax and on what the property would have earned if kept. Restructuring the debt can sometimes give the same relief without a sale, which is why a mortgage broker for investment loans will usually test that option first. Tax law changes that start on 1 July 2027 add a further consideration.

Treat the tax points here as general information and have an accountant confirm the figures for your situation.

What You Gain and Give Up by Selling

Home loan debt is repaid from after-tax income. An owner on the top marginal rate of 45% plus the 2% Medicare levy has to earn about $1.89 before tax to pay $1 of home loan interest. Investment loan interest is generally deductible against rental and other income, so the same owner bears about 53 cents of each $1.

That gap is the case for selling, because it clears the expensive debt first. The case against is that the property is also an asset. It earns rent, it may grow in value and the debt against it is the cheaper kind, so selling removes both the cost and the asset.

The decision comes down to four numbers:

  • Net proceeds after selling costs, tax and the investment loan payout.

  • Home loan interest saved each year by applying those proceeds.

  • After-tax cash flow from the property that you would give up.

  • The capital growth you expect if you hold, which no one can know in advance.

How Much You Keep After Selling

The sale price is not the amount that reaches your mortgage. Three deductions come first, and the tax is the one most often underestimated:

Selling Costs

Agent commission, marketing, conveyancing and any pre-sale repairs come off the top. A working allowance of 2% to 3% of the sale price is common, though it varies by city and agent. Where the investment loan is on a fixed rate, ask the lender for the break cost as well.

Capital Gains Tax

Capital gains tax (CGT) applies to the difference between the sale proceeds and the property's cost base. The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) states that an Australian resident who has owned the asset for at least 12 months can reduce the gain by 50%. The remaining gain is added to taxable income for the year and taxed at your marginal rate.

For 2026-27 the top resident rate is 45% on income above $190,000, plus the Medicare levy. A large gain can push a lower earner into a higher bracket for that year. Depreciation claimed over the years can also reduce the cost base and increase the gain, which is why an accountant's estimate is needed before listing.

Loan Payout

The lender holding the mortgage over the investment property is repaid at settlement before anything is released to you. Where the home and the investment property secure loans with the same lender, the lender may also set how much of the proceeds must reduce debt before it releases the title.

Worked Example of Selling Versus Holding

An anaesthetist in Sydney owns a home with a $600,000 loan and an investment unit in her own name, bought for $700,000 plus $35,000 in purchase costs and now worth $1,100,000. Every figure is illustrative. The example assumes the top marginal rate, ignores depreciation adjustments and uses the tax rules in force as at November 2026:

Step Calculation Amount

Sale price Current value $1,100,000

Selling costs 2.5% of price $27,500

Capital gain $1,100,000 less $27,500 less $735,000 cost base $337,500

Taxable gain after 50% discount 50% of $337,500 $168,750

Tax at 47% 47% of $168,750 $79,313

Investment loan repaid Balance at settlement $450,000

Net proceeds $1,100,000 less $27,500 less $79,313 less $450,000 $543,187

Home loan after sale $600,000 less $543,187 $56,813

The yearly position before and after the sale then looks like this:

Item Amount per Year

Home loan interest saved, $543,187 at 6.25% $33,949

Rent given up, 4% gross yield $44,000

Property expenses no longer paid $11,000

Investment interest no longer paid, $450,000 at 6.50% $29,250

Pre-tax rental cash flow given up $3,750

After-tax rental cash flow given up, at 47% $1,988

Net cash flow improvement from selling $31,961

On cash flow alone, selling comes out well ahead. The missing line is growth. A rise of 4% a year would add $44,000 of value in the first year, before tax on an eventual sale, and a rise of 2% would add $22,000. The owner is choosing between a certain $31,961 a year and an uncertain capital gain, and has paid $79,313 in tax and $27,500 in costs to make the switch.

How the 2027 Tax Changes Affect a Sale

The 2026-27 Federal Budget changed two rules that bear directly on this decision. The ATO confirms the negative gearing and CGT measures are now law and apply from 1 July 2027, with three effects:

  • The 50% CGT discount is replaced for individuals, trusts and partnerships by cost base indexation and a 30% minimum tax rate on capital gains, and the new rules apply only to gains that accrue from 1 July 2027.

  • Negative gearing on residential property is limited to new builds, while properties held at 7:30pm on Budget night, 12 May 2026, are exempt from the change.

  • For established property bought after that time, the Treasury states that losses can be deducted only against residential property income and capital gains, with unused losses carried forward.

Two consequences follow. First, gains already built up are not caught on 1 July 2027, because the new method applies only to gains accruing from that date. Second, a property you already hold has a protected status that a replacement would not have.

Selling an established rental and later buying another established rental means that, from 1 July 2027, the new one cannot be negatively geared against your salary. That raises the cost of changing your mind.

Alternatives to Selling

If the aim is lower repayments or faster reduction of home debt, several changes can deliver part of the result while keeping the asset:

Option What It Does Limits

Refinance or reprice both loans Lowers the rate on the whole debt Requires a fresh assessment, and switching costs apply

Interest-only on the investment loan Frees cash flow that can be directed Investment debt does not reduce, rates are usually

to the home loan higher and terms are limited

Offset account on the home loan Savings reduce non-deductible Needs cash to be effective

interest and remain accessible

Longer home loan term Cuts the required repayment More interest over the life of the loan, and age can limit

the term

Sell a different asset Shares or a weaker property may Each has its own tax result

carry a smaller gain

Of these, refinancing the home loan usually shows soonest how far restructuring alone can move the repayments. Specialist Broking models these loan changes beside the sale figures and leaves the tax calculation to your accountant.

Some owners keep the property and convert home debt into deductible investment debt over time through a debt recycling strategy, which needs tax advice and a lender whose loan structure supports it.

When Selling Makes Sense

Selling is usually the stronger choice when the property is doing little for you and the home debt is a real strain, as in these situations:

  • The property has underperformed for years, with weak growth, high vacancies or large repairs ahead.

  • Holding costs exceed rent by a margin that strains the household budget, and restructuring does not close the gap.

  • Retirement is near and you want the home owned outright before income falls.

  • The capital gain is small, or you have capital losses to offset it.

  • Your income will be lower in the year of sale, for example during parental leave, a sabbatical or the move from full-time work.

  • The property is jointly owned and the gain can be split across two taxpayers on lower rates.

Holding is usually stronger where the property is a sound asset in a supply-constrained location, the shortfall is manageable, your income is secure and you have 10 or more working years ahead.

Loan Checks to Make Before You List

A sale changes your loan position as well as your tax position. Confirm these points with your broker before signing an agency agreement:

  • Break costs on any fixed rate loan and the discharge fee.

  • Whether the two properties are cross-collateralised, and what the lender will require to release one title.

  • Whether to pay the proceeds into the home loan or hold them in an offset account, which matters if the home may become a rental later.

  • How losing the rental income changes your borrowing capacity for any future purchase.

  • Whether the remaining home loan should be re-termed to match your plans.

The Bottom Line

Selling an investment property to clear a home loan trades an uncertain capital gain for a certain interest saving, at the price of selling costs and CGT. The result depends on your purchase price, your tax rate and the property itself.

Before you list, have an accountant work out the net proceeds, then compare the yearly saving with what the property contributes and with the loan alternatives.

If you are weighing up whether to sell an investment property to pay off your home loan, Specialist Broking can talk you through the loan options that suit your circumstances.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is it better to pay off the home loan or keep the investment property?

Neither is better in general. Paying off the home loan gives a certain saving on non-deductible interest. Keeping the property keeps an asset that may grow. The comparison turns on net proceeds, cash flow and your view of the property's prospects.

How much capital gains tax will I pay when I sell?

It depends on the gain, how long you have owned the property and your taxable income in the year of sale. Under the rules in force as at November 2026, a resident who has held the property for at least 12 months can halve the gain before it is taxed at their marginal rate. An accountant should calculate the cost base.

Should I sell before 1 July 2027?

Not for that reason alone. The ATO states the new CGT method applies only to gains that accrue from 1 July 2027, so gains built up before then are not caught by it. How the two methods combine on a later sale is a question for your accountant.

Can I use the sale proceeds on any loan I choose?

Only after the lender holding the mortgage on the sold property has been repaid. If the same lender also holds your home as security, it may set conditions on the release. The remaining funds can then go to the home loan or an offset account.

What if I want to buy another investment property later?

You would pay stamp duty and purchase costs again, and your borrowing capacity would be reassessed at that time. From 1 July 2027, rental losses on an established property bought after 12 May 2026 can only be used against residential property income, not salary.

Should I put the proceeds in the offset or pay down the loan?

Both reduce interest by the same amount. An offset keeps the funds accessible and leaves the loan balance unchanged, which can matter for tax if the home is later rented out. Paying down the loan is simpler if you will never need the money back. Ask your accountant before choosing.

This article is general information only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Lending criteria, government thresholds, interest rates and lender concessions vary and can change without notice. Before acting on anything here, consider speaking with a qualified credit or tax professional who can review your individual circumstances.

Previous
Previous

Pilot Home Loans by Airline: Qantas, Jetstar, Virgin and Rex

Next
Next

Home Loans After 50: Terms and Exit Strategies